The Weekly Standard was an American conservative political opinion and culture magazine published from September 1995 to December 2018 †1 †2. Founded by William Kristol, Fred Barnes, and John Podhoretz with financial backing from Rupert Murdoch's News Corporation, the Washington, D.C.-based magazine was published first by News America Publishing and from June 2009 by Philip Anschutz's Clarity Media Group through its subsidiary MediaDC †3 †4 †5 †6.
During the administration of President George W. Bush, The Weekly Standard became a prominent forum for neoconservatism and advocated the 2003 invasion of Iraq †7 †8. After Donald Trump won the 2016 presidential election, The Weekly Standard adopted an editorial stance critical of the president †9. Clarity Media Group announced the magazine's closure on December 14, 2018, and released its final print issue—Volume 24, Number 16, cover-dated December 24, 2018—on December 17, 2018; former editors and writers subsequently helped launch the digital publications The Bulwark and The Dispatch in 2019 †2 †10 †11.
History
Planning for The Weekly Standard began after the November 1994 midterm elections gave Republicans control of the U.S. House of Representatives †12. William Kristol, who had led the Project for the Republican Future, joined The New Republic veteran Fred Barnes and writer John Podhoretz to found the magazine with financing from Rupert Murdoch's News Corporation †3 †2. Volume 1, Number 1 debuted on September 18, 1995—the same week George launched—with Kristol as editor and publisher, Barnes as executive editor, Podhoretz as deputy editor, and a cover illustration of House Speaker Newt Gingrich by John Kascht †3 †4.
In its early years, The Weekly Standard broke with parts of the Republican base on foreign intervention and presidential politics. When the magazine backed President Bill Clinton's 1995 military intervention in Bosnia while also publishing a dissent by Charles Krauthammer, subscribers canceled in protest †13. Kristol promoted Colin Powell during the 1996 Republican presidential cycle, and Kristol and senior editor David Brooks backed John McCain over George W. Bush in 2000 while advancing a "national greatness" conservatism favorable to active federal leadership and foreign engagement †7.
From the late 1990s onward, The Weekly Standard campaigned for the overthrow of Iraqi president Saddam Hussein, publishing an editorial titled "Saddam Must Go" in November 1997 and co-editorials by Kristol and Robert Kagan after the September 11 attacks urging a U.S. ground invasion of Iraq †14 †15 †7. During the 2008 presidential campaign, Kristol championed Alaska Governor Sarah Palin as a vice-presidential nominee after meeting her during a Weekly Standard-sponsored summer cruise in 2007 †16.
In June 2009, News Corporation sold The Weekly Standard to Denver-based Clarity Media Group, owned by billionaire Philip Anschutz and parent company of the Washington Examiner †17 †5. Clarity Media Group chief executive Ryan McKibben announced the acquisition on June 16, 2009, pledging to expand the magazine's circulation and advertising pages †5. The Daily Beast reported that Anschutz purchased The Weekly Standard for a reported $1 million, while Joe Flint in the Los Angeles Times noted that Murdoch owned the Wall Street Journal and was reviewing print holdings †18 †17.
On December 12, 2016, Clarity Media Group appointed senior writer Stephen F. Hayes as editor-in-chief—a newly created title at the magazine—and deputy editor Richard Starr as editor †19. Kristol stepped down from daily editing after 21 years and became editor-at-large †20. Under Hayes, The Weekly Standard maintained its conservative opposition to Democrats and published investigative and commentary pieces critical of President Donald Trump, including November 2018 audio of Representative Steve King making remarks about Mexican immigrants at an Iowa campaign event †2 †9. That posture produced friction with Clarity Media's publishing unit MediaDC and alienated some Trump-supporting subscribers; meanwhile, MediaDC expanded the Washington Examiner magazine toward a weekly schedule and declined an effort by Hayes and Kristol to arrange a sale of The Weekly Standard to outside buyers †9 †11.
On Friday, December 14, 2018, McKibben informed the staff and announced publicly that The Weekly Standard would shut down; he cited declining revenues and double-digit annual subscriber drops in all but one year since 2013 †2 †21. The magazine's 35-member editorial staff was laid off and offered severance conditioned on non-disclosure and non-disparagement agreements, while the Washington Examiner's revamped weekly magazine assumed fulfillment for remaining The Weekly Standard subscriptions †2 †9. Clarity Media released the final print issue on Monday, December 17, 2018—Volume 24, Number 16, which carried the cover date December 24, 2018—and included Alice B. Lloyd's essay "Last Lines" and John Podhoretz's farewell film column "A Valediction" †2 †1 †10 †8. Following the closure, Kristol and Sarah Longwell co-founded the anti-Trump website The Bulwark in early 2019 with former The Weekly Standard digital editor Jonathan V. Last as editor, and Hayes co-founded The Dispatch with Jonah Goldberg in late 2019 †22 †11.
Publishing history timeline
-
Launch
September 18, 1995William Kristol, Fred Barnes, and John Podhoretz launched The Weekly Standard with financing from Rupert Murdoch's News Corporation, debuting with Volume 1, Number 1.
-
Acquisition by Clarity Media Group
June 16, 2009Clarity Media Group chief executive Ryan McKibben announced that Philip Anschutz's Clarity Media Group had acquired The Weekly Standard from News Corporation.
-
Editorial leadership transition
December 12, 2016Clarity Media Group appointed Stephen F. Hayes as editor-in-chief and Richard Starr as editor while William Kristol became editor-at-large.
-
Closure announced
December 14, 2018Clarity Media Group chief executive Ryan McKibben announced that The Weekly Standard would shut down.
-
Final print issue
December 17, 2018Clarity Media Group released the final print issue of The Weekly Standard, Volume 24, Number 16, which carried the cover date December 24, 2018.
-
Alumni successor launches
2019Former The Weekly Standard editors and staff helped launch The Bulwark in early 2019 and The Dispatch in late 2019.
Editorial profile and coverage
The Weekly Standard combined reported political journalism, unsigned institutional editorials, commentary, and cultural criticism in a weekly print format †3 †13. In Volume 1, Number 1 (September 18, 1995), numbered editorial pages ran from page 4 through page 72 and opened with John Podhoretz's personal essay column "Casual" (p. 4), an unsigned "Editorial" on the federal budget ("Our Kind of Budget Deal," p. 7), political dispatches by Fred Barnes, Kristol ("President Powell?"), Robert Kagan, David McClintick on Gingrich's speakership, and Andrew Ferguson ("Dem Crazy Dems"), the short-items "Scrapbook" section (p. 26), and back-of-book cultural essays by Charles Krauthammer on Gingrich's faith in technology, Tucker Carlson on Mumia Abu-Jamal, Eric Burns on novelist John Grisham, Christopher Caldwell on Sports Illustrated, and Lynne V. Cheney on the film Kids †4 †3.
Across later decades, the magazine standardized a recurring front-to-back order. In the combined August 4 / August 11, 2003 issue (Volume 8, Number 45), the opening "Scrapbook" column appeared on page 2, followed by "Casual" (p. 4), reader letters under "Correspondence" (p. 6), "Editorial" (p. 7), "Articles" including Stephen F. Hayes reporting from Iraq and John Yoo on targeted killings, "Features" on marriage by Maggie Gallagher and Stanley Kurtz, "Books & Arts" reviews, and a closing "Parody" page satirizing Ann Coulter †23. In February 2010 (Volume 15, Number 19), the magazine ran the same core sequence—The Scrapbook, Casual, Editorials, Articles, Features, Books & Arts, and Parody—with a cover story on the election of Senator Scott Brown and essays by Matthew Continetti, Noemie Emery, Barnes, Ferguson, Tod Lindberg, and Podhoretz †24. By December 2018, the front section also included a signed "Comment" subsection before "Articles," and Volume 24, Number 15 (December 17, 2018) ran a back-page "Not a Parody" column alongside Gary Locke's illustrated political covers †25 †10. The final issue (Volume 24, Number 16, cover-dated December 24, 2018) carried a Gary Locke cover caricature of outgoing U.N. Ambassador Nikki Haley ("Not the Retiring Type"), Michael Warren's profile of Haley, Jack Goldsmith on the Justice Department, Joseph Bottum in "Casual," Barnes, Philip Terzian, Adam Keiper, and a closing "Parody" mock White House press release †10.
Politically, The Weekly Standard was closely identified with neoconservatism, an assertive foreign policy, and skepticism toward strict libertarianism †7 †13. At the same time, former staff writer Katherine Mangu-Ward noted that the masthead included anti-war senior editors and non-orthodox conservatives alongside foreign-policy hawks †13.
Ownership, management, and circulation
The Weekly Standard was published under News America Publishing Incorporated (later News America Incorporated) from 1995 until June 2009, with corporate headquarters listed in New York and editorial offices at 1150 17th Street NW, Suite 505, in Washington, D.C. †4 †23 †5. Under Clarity Media Group, the editorial offices remained at 1150 17th Street NW in 2010 and moved by 2018 to 1152 15th Street NW, Suite 200, in Washington, D.C., operated by Clarity Media's publishing unit MediaDC †24 †10.
William Kristol was both editor and publisher at launch in 1995 and edited the magazine until December 12, 2016, when he became editor-at-large †4 †19 †20. Terry Eastland was listed as publisher on the 2003 and 2010 mastheads †23 †24. Fred Barnes was executive editor throughout the magazine's run (joined as co-executive editor by Robert Messenger by 2018), Richard Starr progressed from co-managing editor (1995) to deputy editor (2010) and editor (2016–2018), Christine Rosen was managing editor in 2018, and Stephen F. Hayes was editor-in-chief from December 2016 until the shutdown †4 †24 †19 †10.
At launch in 1995, The Weekly Standard published weekly except for combined issues in August and December, with a cover price of $2.95 ($3.50 in Canada) and a $79.96 U.S. annual subscription rate †4. By 2003, it moved to a 48-issue annual schedule that skipped four weeks per year, with cover prices rising from $3.95 in 2003 to $4.95 in 2010 and $5.99 in 2018 †23 †24 †10 †2.
The Weekly Standard was unprofitable throughout its existence †2. According to the Los Angeles Times in June 2009, the magazine had not been audited by the Audit Bureau of Circulations since 1996, though its mastheads from 2003 and 2018 carried the logo of BPA International (later BPA Worldwide) †17 †23 †10. Reason reported circulation approaching 60,000 in 2006, and The Weekly Standard's website stated a circulation of 83,000 in June 2009 †7 †17. Circulation later topped 100,000 at its peak before declining by roughly half under Clarity Media ownership—including double-digit percentage subscriber drops in all but one year after 2013 and roughly a 10 percent drop during the Trump era †2 †21. By December 2018, the magazine had approximately 50,000 weekly print subscribers †2.
Digital presence
The Weekly Standard had an official website at www.weeklystandard.com †26. By June 2002, the site published daily web commentary, print advance copy, current-issue summaries, and reader polls †27. Jonathan V. Last was listed as online editor by August 2003 (and digital editor in 2018), with John McCormack as online editor in 2010 †23 †24 †10.
By December 2018, the website carried daily news and opinion under "Today," Gregg Easterbrook's "TMQ" column, newsletters, full digital editions of print issues, and the podcasts TWS Podcast and The Substandard †26. The website attracted roughly 2 million unique visitors per month as of December 2018 †2. When announcing the shutdown, Clarity Media Group told CNN that the online archives would remain online initially while McKibben told staff the website would eventually close †9. Selected The Weekly Standard articles are hosted under the "TWS Archive" tag on the Washington Examiner website †28, and digitized print issues are hosted by the Internet Archive †29.
Reception and impact
Commentators across the political spectrum noted that The Weekly Standard exerted political influence larger than its circulation figures. In 2006, Reason quoted liberal columnist Eric Alterman describing the magazine as potentially "the most influential publication in America" on a reader-for-reader basis, while W. James Antle wrote that its writers had moved from conservative commentary into mainstream outlets including CNN, MSNBC, and the New York Times op-ed page †7. Upon its closure, The Guardian wrote that the magazine had provided a platform for core neoconservatives such as John Bolton and David Brooks †8.
The magazine's foreign-policy advocacy drew sustained criticism. Antle faulted its 2005 tenth-anniversary anthology for defending the 2003 Iraq invasion without confronting the post-invasion insurgency or the failure to find weapons of mass destruction †7. Joe Conason in Salon criticized Kristol and The Weekly Standard for backing both the Iraq War and Sarah Palin's 2008 vice-presidential candidacy, while Ed Pilkington in The Guardian wrote that its support for the Iraq invasion remained a contentious part of its record †16 †8. In The New Republic, John Ganz argued in 2020 that The Weekly Standard's 1990s embrace of Gingrichism, Iraq interventionism, and Palin complicated its later anti-Trump identity †11.
The circumstances of the 2018 closure prompted competing explanations. Clarity Media Group CEO Ryan McKibben attributed the decision to subscriber and revenue declines rather than political differences †2 †9. Co-founder John Podhoretz wrote in Commentary that Anschutz closed the magazine to redirect its subscribers toward the Washington Examiner; Podhoretz wrote that anti-Trump sentiment gave ownership a pretext rather than the underlying motive †8. Former staff writer Katherine Mangu-Ward wrote in Reason that the combination of an audience-limiting anti-Trump stance, print-versus-digital tensions, and Clarity Media's decision to build a rival magazine at the Washington Examiner all contributed to the end of The Weekly Standard †13.
External links
- Official website archive (December 14, 2018 capture) on the Wayback Machine
- TWS Archive at the Washington Examiner
- The Weekly Standard digitized issues at the Internet Archive
Citations
- The weekly standard. Library of Congress,
- Paul Farhi.The Weekly Standard, a conservative Trump critic, will shut down.Los Angeles Times, 2018.
- Richard Lacayo.PRESS: AND IN THIS CORNER THE STANDARD.Time, 1995.
- The Weekly Standard (September 18, 1995) (primary source).The Weekly Standard, vol. 1, no. 1, 1995.
- Examiner Staff Writer.Weekly Standard acquired by Washington Examiner parent company (primary source).Washington Examiner, 2009.
- Kelsey Sutton.Conservative Magazine The Weekly Standard Is Shutting Down.Adweek, 2018.Referenced by: †6
- W. James Antle.Thunder on the Center-Right.Reason, 2006.
- Ed Pilkington.Weekly Standard, rightwing magazine opposed to Trump, closes after 23 years.The Guardian, 2018.
- Oliver Darcy.The Weekly Standard, a conservative magazine critical of Trump, to shutter after 23 years.CNN, 2018.
- The Weekly Standard (December 24, 2018) (primary source).The Weekly Standard, vol. 24, no. 16, 2018.
- John Ganz.Finding Neverland.The New Republic, 2020.
- Tod Lindberg.The Weekly Standard and Me (primary source). Hudson Institute, 2018.Referenced by: †12
- Katherine Mangu-Ward.The Weekly Standard Was Wrong About Almost Everything (primary source).Reason, 2019.
- SADDAM MUST Go (primary source).The Weekly Standard, 1997.Referenced by: †14
- Robert Kagan and William Kristol.What to do about Iraq? (primary source).The Weekly Standard, 2002.Referenced by: †15
- Joe Conason.The losers who gave us Sarah Palin.Salon, 2009.
- Joe Flint.News Corp. in talks to unload Weekly Standard to Anschutz.Los Angeles Times, 2009.
- Lloyd Grove.The Weekly Standard Shuts Down After 23 Years.The Daily Beast, 2018.Referenced by: †18
- Corinne Grinapol.Stephen Hayes Is Named Editor in Chief of The Weekly Standard.Adweek, 2016.
- Bill Kristol Steps Down as Weekly Standard Editor.The Daily Beast, 2016.
- The Associated Press.Conservative magazine The Weekly Standard shutters.The Daily Herald, 2018.
- Andrew Beaujon.The Bulwark Was Founded to Oppose Trump. Now What?.Washingtonian, 2021.Referenced by: †22
- The Weekly Standard (August 4 / August 11, 2003) (primary source).The Weekly Standard, vol. 8, no. 45, 2003.
- The Weekly Standard (February 1, 2010) (primary source).The Weekly Standard, vol. 15, no. 19, 2010.
- The Weekly Standard (December 17, 2018) (primary source).The Weekly Standard, vol. 24, no. 15, 2018.Referenced by: †25
- The Weekly Standard | A Weekly Conservative Magazine and Blog of News and Opinion (December 14, 2018 archive) (primary source). The Weekly Standard LLC, 2018.
- The Weekly Standard homepage (June 3, 2002 archive) (primary source). The Weekly Standard, 2002.Referenced by: †27
- TWS Archive (primary source). Washington Examiner,Referenced by: †28
- The Weekly Standard. Internet Archive,Referenced by: †29